If you run a used car lot, you probably keep a mental tally of the basics: how many cars you sold this month, how much you made, and whether the bank account looks healthy. Maybe you glance at your average days on lot or check your gross profit when a deal closes.
But here's the hard truth: the dealers who consistently outperform their market aren't tracking 2 or 3 numbers — they're watching 7 or more KPIs in real time, making small adjustments every week that compound into massive advantages over a year.
The good news? You don't need an MBA or a $400/month analytics platform to track these. You just need to know what to look at — and a system that makes the data visible.
Here are the seven metrics that separate lots that are growing from lots that are just surviving.
Average Days on Lot (DOL)
This is the most important number on your lot, and yet most dealers only check it when a unit starts collecting dust. Average DOL tells you how efficiently your inventory moves. The industry benchmark for independent lots hovers around 45–60 days, but the top-performing dealers push this under 35.
Here's what makes DOL so powerful: every single day a car sits on your lot, it's costing you money — in floor plan interest, insurance, depreciation, and opportunity cost. A car that sits for 90 days hasn't just failed to sell; it's actively eaten into the profit of the cars that did sell.
What to do with it: Set a 45-day aging alert. When a unit crosses that threshold, it needs a price cut, a featured listing, or a wholesale exit strategy. Don't let emotion keep a unit on the lot past its profitable window.
Inventory Turn Rate
While DOL tells you how long individual cars sit, turn rate tells you how efficiently your entire lot cycles through inventory over time. Think of it as your lot's metabolism. A higher turn rate means you're moving capital faster and compounding your returns.
A 30-unit lot selling 25 cars per month has a turn rate of 10x annually. That same lot selling 15 cars per month? Just 6x. The difference isn't incremental — it's the difference between a lot that's reinvesting profit and one that's treading water.
What to do with it: Calculate your turn rate monthly. If it's trending downward, you're either buying the wrong cars, pricing them too high, or not marketing aggressively enough. This single number tells you when to hit the gas and when to pump the brakes on acquisitions.
Front-End Gross Profit per Unit
Total revenue is a vanity metric. What actually matters is how much you're keeping on each deal after the cost of the vehicle, reconditioning, and any buyer incentives. This is your front-end gross — and tracking it per unit prevents you from hiding bad deals behind volume.
The danger of only tracking total monthly gross is that it masks the spread between your home runs and your losses. You might feel great about a $12K month until you realize two units lost $800 each and one lucky deal carried the rest.
What to do with it: Review gross per unit on every single deal. Look at the distribution, not just the average. If more than 20% of your deals are below $1,500 front gross, you have an acquisition or pricing problem.
Cost to Market Ratio
Here's a metric most independent dealers have never even heard of — but it's one of the most predictive indicators of whether a car will sell profitably. Cost to market compares what you paid for a vehicle to what similar vehicles are currently selling for in your market.
A cost-to-market ratio of 82% means you bought the car at 82% of what the market is paying — giving you 18 points of margin to work with before you even think about reconditioning. A ratio of 95%? You're fighting uphill from the start.
What to do with it: Check this ratio before you buy, not after. If you can't acquire a unit at 85% or below of current market value, seriously consider walking away. The best profit is made at the auction, not on the lot.
Lead-to-Sale Conversion Rate
You're spending time and money generating leads — from your website, listing platforms, walk-ins, and referrals. But how many of those leads actually become deals? Most independent dealers have no idea. They know they're "busy" but can't tell you their conversion rate to save their life.
If you're converting at 5%, doubling your lead flow won't save you — you'll just waste more opportunities. But improving from 5% to 10% has the same effect on sales as doubling your marketing spend, at zero additional cost.
What to do with it: Track conversion by source. Your website leads might convert at 12% while marketplace leads convert at 4%. That tells you exactly where to invest your time and marketing dollars. A CRM that tracks lead sources automatically makes this effortless.
Reconditioning Cost per Unit
This is the silent profit killer. Most dealers know roughly what they spend on recon, but few track it per unit, per category, or versus the original estimate. The spread between a $400 recon and a $1,800 recon on the same $15K car is the difference between a great deal and a break-even deal.
The problem isn't that recon is expensive — it's that it's invisible. Costs pile up across multiple vendors and weeks of work, and by the time the car hits the front line, nobody can tell you the true total investment. That means your asking price might already be underwater.
What to do with it: Log every dollar of recon against the VIN as it happens. Set a maximum recon budget per unit before work begins. If the estimate exceeds your threshold, wholesale the unit instead of throwing good money after bad.
Return on Investment per Unit (ROI)
This is the ultimate metric — the one KPI that ties everything else together. Unit-level ROI accounts for acquisition cost, reconditioning, holding costs, and final sale price to tell you the true return on every dollar invested in a specific car.
Here's why ROI is superior to gross profit alone: a $3,000 gross on a $30K car you held for 90 days is a terrible ROI. A $1,800 gross on a $12K car you turned in 18 days is a fantastic ROI. The goal isn't to maximize profit per deal — it's to maximize return on capital deployed.
What to do with it: Calculate annualized ROI by factoring in turn speed. A car earning 15% gross in 20 days is generating a dramatically higher annualized return than a car earning 25% gross in 75 days. This reframes your entire approach to which cars you should buy and how aggressively you should price them.
Putting It All Together
The pattern here is clear: the dealers who win aren't just working harder — they're measuring the right things and making data-driven adjustments every single week.
You don't need seven separate spreadsheets or a full-time analyst. You need a system that captures these numbers automatically as you do what you already do — add inventory, close deals, collect payments — and surfaces the insights in a dashboard you'll actually look at.
That's exactly what we built LotPulse to do.
"You can't manage what you don't measure. But more importantly, you won't measure what isn't easy to see. The best system is one that puts the right numbers in front of you without asking you to hunt for them."
Start with whichever KPI feels most relevant to your lot today. Track it consistently for 30 days. Then add the next one. Within a quarter, you'll have visibility into your business that puts you ahead of 90% of independent dealers.
Track All 7 KPIs — Automatically
LotPulse calculates these metrics in real time from your inventory and sales data. No spreadsheets. No guessing. Just open your dashboard.
Get Started →